The matchResolvedUpset
Premier League: Manchester City vs Aston Villa
Manchester City 1, Aston Villa 2
Crowd and market both called 3 of 5 legs.
VoxPop gap highlight
Will Manchester City win by 2 or more goals?
75%Crowd
56%Market
+19Divergence

+19 ppts divergence with the market.

The crowd called yes on will manchester city win by 2 or more goals.

QuestionMarketCrowdGap
1Will Manchester City win by 2 or more goals?Biggest gap56%75% yes+19
2Will there be 3 or more goals scored?74%58% yes-16
3Who leads at half-time?58%73% Manchester City FC+15
4Will both teams score?61%73% yes+12
5Who wins?74%73% Manchester City FC-1
How it landed:UpsetManchester City 1, Aston Villa 2 — full per-leg reconciliation below.
The market price is a yardstick, not a recommendation; the crowd's read is sentiment, not a prediction or financial advice.
Detailed match data
How the crowd called it
3 / 5questions the crowd called · 3 alongside the market · 2 surprises
winsSurprise
both teams scoreCrowd & market agreed
leads at half-timeCrowd & market agreed
there be 3 or more…Crowd & market agreed
Manchester City win by…Surprise
The crowd's read
Top scenario21%share in the most-picked scenario
Cross-market correlationModeratehow much answers moved together
Voters91World ID voters
How the crowd voted per leg
1Who wins?
Manchester City FC73%
Aston Villa FC20%
Draw8%
OutcomeAston Villa FC
Voters91
ReadUpset
2Will both teams score?
yes73%
no27%
Outcomeyes
Voters91
ReadConsensus
3Who leads at half-time?
Manchester City FC73%
Aston Villa FC18%
Draw10%
OutcomeManchester City FC
Voters91
ReadConsensus
4Will there be 3 or more goals scored?
yes58%
no42%
Outcomeyes
Voters91
ReadConsensus
5Will Manchester City win by 2 or more goals?
yes75%
no25%
Outcomeno
Voters91
ReadUpset
Crowd vs market · every leg

How the crowd's read sat against the betting price on every question. The market's a yardstick, not a call: Deep = liquid enough to trust, Thin = directional only.

Who wins: Manchester City FCUpset
Mkt 74%Crowd 73%-1pp
Result: Aston Villa FC · 1.18
: Deep
Will both teams score: yesConsensus
Mkt 61%Crowd 73%+12pp
Result: yes · 0.15
: Deep
Who leads at half-time: Manchester City FCConsensus
Mkt 58%Crowd 73%+15pp
Result: Manchester City FC · 0.12
: Thin
Will there be 3 or more goals scored: yesConsensus
Mkt 74%Crowd 58%-16pp
Result: yes · 0.35
: Deep
Will Manchester City win by 2 or more goals: yesUpset
Mkt 56%Crowd 75%+19pp
Result: no · 1.13
: Deep
The crowd's calibration · Brier
The crowd's calibration, question by question
Who wins1.18
Will both teams score0.15
Who leads at half-time0.12
Will there be 3 or more goals scored0.35
Will Manchester City win by 2 or more goals1.13
Average0.58
Brier scores how well-calibrated the crowd was on each question: 0 is a perfect, confident, correct call · ~0.25 is a coin-flip · higher means the crowd leaned away from what happened. Computed from the crowd's own vote split vs what actually happened — no betting market involved.
VoxPop top scenarios
51% of voters backed the top 3 scenarios · 91 voters
The crowd's map · top scenarios

★ = the cell that actually happened; ♥ = the crowd's most-backed. × is how much more the crowd clustered on a combination than answering each question independently predicts — a cross-leg correlation a per-leg market can't price (overall TV-distance Moderate).

The crowd's top scenariosJoint distribution
Crowd scenariosWho wins?Will both teams score?Who leads at half-time?Will there be 3 or more goals scored?Will Manchester City win by 2 or more goals?
121%19 voters
Manchester City FCGot it wrong
yesCalled it!
Manchester City FCCalled it!
yesCalled it!
yesGot it wrong
1.2×
219%17 voters
Manchester City FCGot it wrong
yesCalled it!
Manchester City FCCalled it!
noGot it wrong
yesGot it wrong
1.5×
311%10 voters
Manchester City FCGot it wrong
noGot it wrong
Manchester City FCCalled it!
yesCalled it!
yesGot it wrong
1.8×
44%4 voters
Manchester City FCGot it wrong
noGot it wrong
Manchester City FCCalled it!
noGot it wrong
yesGot it wrong
1.0×
54%4 voters
Manchester City FCGot it wrong
yesCalled it!
Manchester City FCCalled it!
yesCalled it!
noCalled it!
0.8×
63%3 voters
Aston Villa FCCalled it!
noGot it wrong
Aston Villa FCGot it wrong
noGot it wrong
noCalled it!
32.3×
73%3 voters
Aston Villa FCCalled it!
yesCalled it!
Aston Villa FCGot it wrong
yesCalled it!
noCalled it!
8.7×
82%2 voters
Manchester City FCGot it wrong
yesCalled it!
Aston Villa FCGot it wrong
yesCalled it!
yesGot it wrong
0.5×
92%2 voters
Aston Villa FCCalled it!
yesCalled it!
Manchester City FCCalled it!
yesCalled it!
yesGot it wrong
0.5×
102%2 voters
Manchester City FCGot it wrong
yesCalled it!
DrawGot it wrong
yesCalled it!
yesGot it wrong
0.9×
Each row is one full scenario the crowd could pick, most-backed first (91 voters · top 10 of 31 combinations). vs ind. above 1× means the crowd clustered on that exact combination together.
0.35How far the crowd's whole picture sat from treating each question on its own. 0 = they answered independently; closer to 1 = the questions moved together.
Clustering on the top call1.2×The most-backed combination drew 1.2× as many voters as separate answers would predict — the crowd piled onto it together.
Rarity of the top call1-in-5The crowd put its top scenario at about 1-in-5; answering each question separately implies ~1-in-6. Shorter odds = more crowd conviction.
How right was the crowd · alignment
5 / 50 · 0%
4 / 510 · 11%
3 / 531 · 34%
2 / 543 · 47%
1 / 57 · 8%
0 / 50 · 0%
Legs each complete ballot got right (n=91). Average 2.48 / 5.
Crowd sentiment is shown only after a poll closes — never mid-vote. "Crowd called it" means the crowd's top pick matched the result; it is not a claim the crowd is right in general. Aggregate data from World ID voters — a crowd view, not a prediction or advice.
VoxPop
Our insights are a read-only record of what our World ID holders expressed in our polls, not VoxPop predictions. The crowd's read is not to be considered financial advice.
Get the calls worth watching